At high volume you are not just saving fees — a negative maker rate means the exchange pays you a rebate, and you capture spread on round-trips. But adverse selection and hedging eat into it. This adds up the real monthly market-making P&L: rebate + spread capture − adverse selection − hedge cost − overhead, plus the break-even adverse-selection rate.
✓ No signup✓ Net P&L in $ and bps✓ Break-even adverse rate✓ Sensitivity table
Net market-making P&L (per month)
—
Where the P&L comes from
The rebate and captured spread are income; adverse selection, hedging and overhead are costs. The net is what actually lands in the account.
Component
Monthly ($)
bps of volume
Net P&L across adverse-selection rates
Adverse selection is the swing factor. This holds everything else fixed and steps the adverse rate to show where net flips from profit to loss — the break-even row is marked.
Adverse selection (bps)
Adverse cost ($)
Net P&L ($)
Verdict
The rebate is the easy part
It is tempting to read a negative maker fee as a licence to print money: post orders, collect the rebate, repeat. The rebate really is income, and at scale it is a large number — but it is the only part of market making that is easy to compute, which is exactly why it misleads. The hard parts are the costs that do not show up on the fee schedule. Adverse selection is the big one: your resting orders get filled most eagerly by the traders who know something you do not, so your average fill is worse than the mid-price you quoted around, and that gap, measured in basis points across your whole volume, is a real drain. Keeping inventory flat means occasionally paying the taker fee to hedge, and running the whole thing costs money whether or not the market cooperates. This calculator lays all of that out: it turns your volume and maker rate into a rebate, adds the spread you actually capture when both legs of a round-trip fill as maker, then subtracts adverse selection, hedging and overhead to leave a net P&L in dollars and in basis points of volume. The single most useful output is the break-even adverse-selection rate — the amount of getting-picked-off your quotes can survive before the strategy stops paying. If you are instead a directional trader deciding whether a limit order beats a market order, the maker vs taker savings calculator is the right tool; to see when chasing a lower fee tier is worth the extra volume, use the fee tier break-even calculator; and to fold fees, spread and slippage into one hurdle on a single trade, use the true trade cost calculator.
The math
Write monthly maker volume as V and the maker rate as m (a percent, negative for a rebate). The rebate income is −V · m ÷ 100, which is positive when m is negative. The spread income is V · f · s ÷ 10000, where f is the round-trip fill rate (the fraction of maker volume that completes a both-sides-as-maker round-trip and captures the spread) and s is the spread captured per round-trip in basis points.
On the cost side, adverse selection is V · a ÷ 10000 for an adverse rate a in basis points; the hedge cost is V · h · t ÷ 100 where h is the hedged fraction and t the taker fee percent; and F is fixed monthly overhead. The net P&L is rebate + spread − adverse − hedge − F, and the net margin in basis points is net ÷ V · 10000. Setting net to zero and solving for the adverse rate gives the break-even adverse selection a* = (rebate + spread − hedge − F) ÷ (V ÷ 10000) — the basis points of getting picked off the book can absorb before it bleeds. All figures are notional-weighted and ignore financing, latency losses and queue position, which in practice determine how much of the quoted spread and rebate you actually realise.
A maker rebate is a negative fee: instead of charging you to trade, the exchange pays you for adding liquidity with a resting limit order that another trader fills. Most retail traders only ever see a positive maker fee, but at higher volume tiers and on some venues' market-maker programmes the maker rate goes negative — commonly in the range of minus 0.005% to minus 0.015% of notional. On that volume the rebate becomes a real income stream: a market maker turning over hundreds of millions of dollars a month collects the rebate on every filled maker order. This calculator takes your monthly maker volume and your maker rate (enter it negative for a rebate) and turns it into a dollar figure, then nets it against the costs that come with actually running the strategy — because the rebate on its own is never the whole story.
Why isn't the rebate just free money?
Because market making has real costs that the headline rebate hides, and the biggest one is adverse selection. When you post a resting order, the trades that hit it are disproportionately the ones on the wrong side for you: informed flow picks off your bid just before price drops and your ask just before it rises, so your fills are systematically worse than mid. That is a genuine cost measured in basis points of volume, and on a thin rebate it can easily swamp the income. On top of that, keeping inventory flat usually means hedging some fills with taker orders that pay the taker fee, and there is fixed overhead — colocation, market-data feeds, servers and development. This calculator subtracts all three — adverse selection, hedge cost and fixed monthly overhead — from the rebate and spread income, so the number at the bottom is the P&L that actually lands in your account, not the gross rebate.
How much adverse selection can a maker rebate absorb?
That is exactly the break-even the calculator solves for. Adverse selection is the swing factor in market making: a strategy that looks profitable on paper turns into a slow bleed the moment your fills are being picked off faster than the rebate and spread pay you. The break-even adverse-selection rate is the level, in basis points of maker volume, at which your net P&L hits zero — below it you make money, above it you lose. It is found by taking all your income (rebate plus captured spread) minus your controllable costs (hedging and overhead), then dividing by your volume to express the remainder as the basis points of adverse selection you can tolerate. Knowing that number tells you how tight your quoting and how fast your cancels have to be: if your break-even is 2 basis points and your measured adverse selection is 1.2, you have margin; if it is 0.5, one bad regime wipes the month.
How is this different from a maker-vs-taker savings calculator?
A maker-vs-taker savings calculator answers a retail question: how much do I save by posting a limit order instead of crossing the spread? It compares one positive fee against another and reports the difference. This calculator answers a market-maker question: if I run resting liquidity at scale, what does the business actually earn? That means starting from a rebate (a negative fee) rather than a saving, adding the spread you capture when both sides of a round-trip fill as maker, and then subtracting the costs unique to providing liquidity — adverse selection, inventory hedging and fixed overhead. The output is a monthly profit-and-loss and a net margin in basis points, not a per-trade saving. In short, the savings calculator is for someone deciding how to place a single order; this one is for someone deciding whether running a market-making book is worth it at all.